Pundit: Google decision to ban political ads acknowledges the problem, but offers no clear solution
Google's announcement that it's limiting political advertising has been met with criticism from US President Donald Trump's re-election campaign and a number of top GOP Committees, who said the move will influence voter turnout, APA reports citing Sputnik.
"Google's latest arbitrary rule changes are a blatant attempt to suppress voter information, knowledge, and engagement in the 2020 election", the Trump campaign together with the Republican National Committee, National Republican Senatorial Committee, and the National Republican Congressional Committee said in a joint statement on Tuesday. "These actions will lead directly to suppressing voter turnout", they stressed.
On Wednesday, Google announced that it would no longer allow political advertisers to target voters on political affiliation.
The US tech giant said in its blog that it would only permit political groups to target ads based on "general categories": age, gender, and general location and that contextual targeting will be allowed.
"This is obviously a difficult issue - ideally, we want citizens to get factual political information, and misinformation can cause serious problems (not only with people accepting false information as true but with how the acceptance of that false information influences their future information search and acquisition)", Steve Utych, an assistant professor of political science at Boise State University, pointed out.
But according to the academic, to determine what is factual and what is not will be quite difficult in some situations.
"Imagine a candidate says they have a tax plan that will lower taxes on everyone making less than $80,000 per year. However, their plan in reality only lowers taxes for those making less than $79,800 per year. That's technically a false statement, but it's not an especially misleading statement", Utych explained.
"Fact-checking may lead candidates to make more vague, rather than specific, statements, which might lead to a general, lower amount of information about candidates", the scholar noted, adding that he fears there's no good blanket solution to this issue.
Giving another example, he noted that when people make subjective statements it becomes even more problematic.
"One can easily imagine a Democratic candidate for president saying 'Donald Trump is the worst president in American history'. This statement is certainly subjective, and nearly impossible to fact check. Does that count as misinformation, or opinion?"
Determining what is political and what is not is another tricky area that would need to be made more clear.
When it comes to Google ad targeting, Utych believes that it's a reasonable solution, if not a clear one though, but "one can easily infer political leanings based on other targeted data, such as race, age, gender, income, education, and location".
Google has information on individuals, a lot of it. And the expert has expressed doubt that the new measures will really change the way it operates.
"I'm not sure simply not being able to use Google's predictions on political leanings will stop targeting based on political leanings - it just moves the modelling and prediction from Google onto other organisations. It seems highly unlikely that Google or anywhere else would stop all kinds of microtargeting, which is a huge moneymaker for them", the academic stressed.
Utych says that Google's decision acknowledges that there is a problem, but offers no clear solution:
"This is a step in the direction of trying to solve this issue, but it may have unintended consequences -- campaigns may need to spend more money to reach the same amount of people, giving even more of an advantage to well-funded candidates", he concluded.
Google's restrictions have already been introduced in the UK, ahead of the general election slated for 12 December, and will be enforced in the European Union by the end of the year, and in the rest of the world starting 6 January 2020.
Google's move follows a decision by Twitter to ban political ads in its feed starting 22 November.
But Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg, on the other hand, has defended his social media platform's free speech policy, refusing to ban the ads.
Zuckerberg said in October that it's not right for "private companies to censor political ads or the news" and that "nobody would want to live in a world where you can only post things that tech companies judge to be 100% true".
Trump impeachment prosecutor, Adam Schiff, is becoming Exhibit A in president's defense
State Department declines UK extradition request for diplomat's wife involved in deadly car crash
Trump says plans to release Middle East Peace Plan sometime prior to Netanyahu visit
U.S. health officials seek emergency approval to use diagnostic test for new coronavirus
Netanyahu, rival to be in Washington next week to discuss Mideast peace plan -U.S. official
14 killed, 300 injured as massive quake of magnitude 6.9 rocks Turkey - UPDATED-2 - VIDEO
Trump impeachment prosecutor, Adam Schiff, is becoming Exhibit A in president's defense
Consultations held on the settlement of the Nagorno Garabagh conflict at the Russian Foreign Ministry
Rolls-Royce planning to power UK with Tiny Nuclear reactors by end of decade
French Health Minister confirms two cases of coronavirus
London police to deploy facial recognition cameras
U.S. says 34 troops diagnosed with traumatic brain injury after Iran strike
Second case of coronavirus confirmed in U.S.
Senior official: "EU assumes post-Brexit transition finishes at end-2020"
Uzbekistan to ease restrictions on moving from provinces to capital
Turkey joins 4th Industrial Revolution Network of WEF
Kremlin: UN SC permanent members’ summit needed to find ways of easing global tensions
Some parts of China's Great Wall closed to visitors
Kremlin: Russia’s public vote on constitutional amendments not to be formality
Two Russian diplomats declared persona non grata in Bulgaria - Embassy
Erdogan: "Turkish-German University symbol of friendship"
European Union appoints first head of EU delegation in London
Sri Lanka to host International Army Games contest for first time
Erdogan: Turkey determined not to leave Libyan brothers
Main symptoms of coronavirus
Saudi Arabia says all options open at OPEC+ meeting, including further cuts
Bakcell and INNOLAND introduced young developers to the potential investors
Massive locust swarms spark UN appeal for help
Six dead in shooting in German town
President of Turkish Supreme Electoral Council changed
An explosion at a manufacturing business has shaken northwest Houston
Foreign Ministry warns Azerbaijani citizens about the deadly virus in China
Mnuchin: "U.S. wants trade deal done with UK this year"
EU, China, other WTO members agree temporary body to settle disputes
Baku and Moscow sign protocol on cultural cooperation
WHO: Coronavirus human-to-human transmission is registered
McDonalds closes outlets in five Chinese cities
Kremlin: No plans for Putin-Zelensky meeting, but can be quickly arranged if needed
Mikhail Gusman expresses gratitude to Azerbaijani President
Turkish FM receives European Parliament Rapporteur on Turkey
Russian Defense Ministry invites NATO countries to Army Games 2020
Israeli national Issachar must appeal for pardon to be granted one, Kremlin says
Coronavirus thread: Special wards allocated, border and customs checkpoints switched to an enhanced mode
Ambassador: “I believe that Trump will contribute to settlement of Israeli-Palestinian conflict”
Executive Director of WHO dies
Azerbaijani President and mayor of Montrés, Switzerland meet in Davos
President Ilham Aliyev met with Chief Executive Officer of Equinor in Davos
Armenian Deputy Minister of Education's apartment robbed
Two Armenian servicemen shot in Nagorno Garabagh
Turkish President: "Libya chaos to impact entire Mediterranean region"
Former CHP leader Deniz Baykal hospitalized
Exhibition of Azerbaijani carpets to open at UNESCO’s headquarters
China welcomes Russia’s initiative to hold summit of UNSC permanent members
WHO recommends all countries brace for further expansion of coronavirus
Umayra Taghieva: "Height of the waves on Oil Rocks reached 3.2 m"
Troops of the Nakhchivan garrison hold training sessions on the various specialties - VIDEO
Official Facebook page of President Ilham Aliyev posted a video dedicated to the 30th anniversary of the tragedy on January 20 - VIDEO
China, U.S. sign initial trade pact but doubts and tariffs linger
New video shows Iranian missiles downing Ukraine passenger jet - VIDEO
14 years pass since establishment of the Ministry of Emergency Situations: They always come to your aid in any difficult moments - PHOTOSESSION - VIDEO
First Vice-President Mehriban Aliyeva attended opening ceremony of rebuilt Azerbaijan pavilion at Exhibition of Achievements of National Economy in Moscow - UPDATED
Open Doors Day and the military oath-taking ceremony were held on the occasion of the State Flag Day
An exhibition that also presents President Ilham Aliyev's photo opened in Moscow
Azerbaijani President and first lady inaugurated Koroglu Transport Exchange Center of Baku Transport Agency - UPDATED
Police detain 185 climate protesters at Brussels car show
Iran to send black boxes of downed Ukrainian plane to Ukraine
Number of candidates registered for early parliamentary elections in Azerbaijan reaches 1622
Azerbaijan's position in the Corruption Perception Index revealed